Comparison between MacPherson Double Wishbone Suspension Systems

-

Comparison between MacPherson Double Wishbone Suspension Systems

            Two of the most popular suspensions systems for passenger cars today are the double-wishbone suspension system and the MacPherson strut suspension system. While it is more usual to see the double-wishbone system at the rear end of the car, MacPherson’s solution normally finds its place at the front end of the car. Both types of suspensions have their own sets of benefits and limitations, thus let us look at both the advantages and disadvantages of both systems, starting with the simpler of the two, the MacPherson struts.

 

MacPherson Struts:

            The struts are designed with more simplicity, and thus takes up less space horizontally. As a result, passengers get more compartment place in the car. They also display low un-sprung weight, an advantage that reduces the overall weight of the vehicle as well as increases the car’s acceleration. Lower unsprung weight also makes your ride more comfortable. Another major advantage of this system is its ease of manufacturing as well as the low cost of manufacture compared to other stand-alone suspension systems. Without an upper arm, the suspension system designers can directly block vibration from reaching the passenger compartment.

            Nevertheless, the MacPherson struts come with their own drawbacks. Being a long, vertical assembly, you would encounter difficulties if you lower your car as they may be a collision with the structure of your car. Thus they do not work well with racing cars that are normally lowered. The MacPherson struts also have problems working with wider wheels that have increased scrub radius, where you would need extra effort to navigate your car in this situation. There is also the problem with the small camber change with the vertical movement of the suspension, which could mean the tires have less contact with the road during cornering. This could reduce the handling abilities of your vehicle.

 

Double Wishbone Suspension System:

            One of its primary benefits is the increase of the negative chamber as a result of the vertical suspension movement of the upper and lower arms. This translates to better stability properties for the car as the tires on the outside maintain more contact with the road surface. Handling performance also increases. The double suspension system is much more rigid and stable than other suspension systems, thus you would realize that your steering and wheel alignments are constant even when undergoing high amounts of stress.


            Moving on to the drawbacks of the double-wishbone suspension system, it is normally bugged by cost issues as it is a more complicated design to produce. There are many parts to the system, and thus every time any of these malfunctions fail, your whole system fails. Repair, modification, and maintenance costs and complexities for double-wishbone suspension systems are normally higher due to these reasons. This suspension system also proves to be flexible for design engineers, as the arms of the system can be fixed at different angles to the surface, parameters such as camber gain, roll center height, and swingarm length can be determined and designed flexibly to suit and the road surface in condition.

            As we have seen, both suspension systems have their own plus points and limitations. To conclude, double wishbones may perform better, but the MacPherson struts would prove to be more affordable in the long run.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Types of Flexible Coupling – Bibby Resilient Couplings

-
Image
Types of Flexible Coupling – Bibby Resilient Couplings                  Named after its Inventor Dr. James Bibby in 1917, this coupling is still one of the most sought after flexible couplings for heavy shock applications. Let us now look at the constructional features of the coupling. 1.       The Coupling consists of two flanges or hubs specifically mounted on the drive and the driven shafts respectively. These hubs contain axial grooves cut on their circumference. 2.       The two couplings are joined or held together by means of a specially designed grid spring. 3.       The total assembly is enclosed in a casing or shell filled with grease for low-speed applications or, in high-speed applications with high viscosity oil. Now let’s look at the working aspect of the coupling and how it tends to reduce vibration and prevents the build-up of resonance in the system. a.) The specially designed spring is wound up through the grooves forming a series of resilient bridges throughout the p
Read more

Safety Systems in Vehicles | Seat Belts | Air Bags

-
Image
Safety Systems in Vehicles | Seat Belts | Air Bags Seat belts                The function of the seat belts is to restrain the occupants of a vehicle in their seats when the vehicle hits an obstacle:                Three-point seat belt: In motoring history, this is the single most significant advance. All credit goes to Volvo’s Nils Bolin for devising it and to Volvo for introducing it in 1959. The three-pointer afforded unrivaled restraint. Its use was a quick, easy one-handed operation. Many improvements have been made to the webbing, mountings, latches, and inertia reels and belts have got smarter in relating to accident severity and occupant weight. In the present day vehicles, seat belts have become mandatory for the driver and front passenger. Some vehicles have seat belts for rear passengers also.                Seat belt pre-tensioner: A spring-loaded or explosive device that reacts to a severe frontal impact by automatically snugging the seat belt tight for fully effective re
Read more

What Is Nvh ???

-
Image
What Is Nvh ? Noise:                Noise is defined as an unpleasant or unexpected sound created by a vibrating object. Vibration:                Vibration is defined as any objectionable repetitive motion of an object, back-and-forth or up-and-down. Harshness:                Harshness is defined as an aggressive suspension feel or lack of “give” in response to a single input. Noise and Vibration Theory:                A vibrating object normally produces sound, and that sound may be an annoying noise. In the case where a vibrating body is the direct source of noise (such as combustion causing the engine to vibrate), the vibrating body or source is easy to find. In other cases, the vibrating body may generate a small vibration only. This small vibration may cause a larger vibration or noise due to the vibrating body’s contact with other parts. When this happens, attention focuses on where the large vibration or noise occurs while the real source often escapes notice.                 A
Read more